BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra
Rumon Gamba Conductor
CHANDOS CHSA 5380
What a shock to realise that Handley’s Hebridean Symphony on Hyperion was recorded (in my case) literally half a lifetime ago!
Not quite a symphony yet more than a suite, the piece requires less interpretation than commitment – which it receives here in spades. If the best melodies are borrowed, the composer makes splendid use of them, from the atmospheric opening to the soaring Technicolor peroration.
With Edwardian spaciousness Bantock takes his time: his vamp-till-ready sequences may test the patience, but this is not a work of Sibelian cogency, and there is real swagger and urgency where required, while the superb recording reveals orchestral details I had never heard before. (e.g. the notorious three note trumpet figure in the third movement never obscures the ravishing harmonic progressions in the body of the orchestra.)
The Prelude certainly feels like a prelude, being neither quite one thing nor another; if intended to portray the events of Euripides drama, it feels oddly incomplete, albeit full of intriguing moments and ideas. The only previous recording is over two minutes longer, which does seem to give the piece more consequence.
It would be hard to pin down these English Scenes geographically; any occasional Englishness is in the generalised manner of Quilter or even Coates, while the music more often evokes the ballroom than the byre. A first hearing left me unimpressed, but closer acquaintance reveals a leisurely and sepia charm.
His publishers insisted on following a rather glum Processional with a Hornpipe, but if intended to rival Henry Wood’s I cannot see Prommers stamping their feet to this one. It is all agreeable enough, but I feel there must be stronger candidates for revival, such as the ravishing Sea Wanderers.
So, close but no cigar? Well maybe a cigarillo. If nothing here matches the profundity and poetry of Sappho, two of the three works here are well worth knowing: and if Handley is a shade more dramatic, the richer sound gives this recording the edge, so that this enterprising disc merits a hearty welcome, and a hope that it will not be the last.
Review by Kevin Mandry